Expertise and engagement

One funny thing about doing a PhD is that you enter into the status of An Expert. By the end of the process, you should know more than anyone about this one tiny area you’ve studied in a very specific way. And PhDs can be very tiny and deep in scope. So one of the first tasks of the research project is to draw a line around what it’s possible and interesting for you to study, and in what way.

description of how my research relates to things I can be quoted on - see text

Outside of the academy, however, other people can often over-estimate your area of knowledge, or spend immense amounts of energy attacking your right to speak about a subject, and sometimes both at the same time. Yoga scholars are often dismissed for not knowing enough Sanskrit, or having a guru, or a long personal practice, or visiting India regularly enough, or all manner of reasons. But it is possible to study something and be an outsider to it. It’s equally possible to study something and be an insider too. You just need to be open and clear about how you know what you know.

description of valid research as containing both insider and outsider research - see text

Meanwhile, in the past few years here in the UK, university researchers have been expected to measure not just the academic quality of what they do, but also the impact and engagement. The highest quality research makes change happen in the world. Maybe policies are rewritten, or guidance changed, or a professional body has a conference on what you have found out. That’s the impact. Engagement means speaking back to your research community and other non-academics about what you do. For example, this weekend I’m talking to yoga students about the most up-to-date research into the history of yoga. Impact and engagement. You can see why people might think it’s important, and why the old image of an academic tucked away in an ivory tower somewhere and never seeing the outside world is increasingly outdated.

description of the tension between engagement and thesis requirements - see text

But as a PhD researcher, my project will take, in total, between 4 and 6 years. At the end of that, I need to produce a thesis that makes a substantial contribution to new knowledge. That means the ideas in it should be all new, and all my own. It is possible to get 6 months from submitting a thesis and find out someone else beat you to publishing similar research. It doesn’t happen often, but the fear of it keeps PhD students awake at night.

So, here’s the deal. I both need and want to share what I’m finding out with non-academic groups. All the things I know about other people’s research I can share with anyone. But I need to be a little careful about what I share of my own research for a while. And if you want to interview me, on record, as ‘an academic’ rather than as a yoga teacher, I can’t speak to things that aren’t in my area. That would be misrepresenting myself. That includes things I know about other people’s research. I can share historical research, but I can’t claim to be a historian.

For now, and probably until the end of my PhD, if I have the time, I will enthusiastically come to speak to groups of interested people; bearing pretty pictures and booklists and a lot of knowledge and I will talk about a number of things related to yoga, British counter-culture, paganism, animism, bodies, movement and consciousness in ways most people can understand.

Just as an example, over two Saturdays this March, I’ll be covering these subjects:

  • The History of Yoga: what we really know, from ancient images to medieval alchemy, to what your great grandmother learnt in gym class.
  • Radical Lineage: the problem with gurus, corporate mindfulness, and who really benefits from you eating 5 a day. With sweet stories of radical yogis, from Thoreau to Angela Farmer to Occupy Gandhi and the Calais Ashram Kitchen, and the mischief they’ve caused.
  • How Do We Know? A brief detour into the most up-to-date knowledge I can find about what works and how concerning the benefits and risks of yoga.
  • What Neuroscience Tells Us: Moving swiftly on to the really cool science of how we move and mimic others, and how that structures our identities and how we communicate with others.description of topics I can talk on - see text

If you’re interested, in return, I ask only that you cover my expenses in full.

That means I get fed, and my travel costs covered, and if it’s a long day or an overnight, someone gives me a bed to sleep in. Pleasant company, gallons of herbal tea, good quality chocolate and quiet spaces to practice in are a definite bonus. Any location considered. Ask me while I’m still super-enthusiastic and cheap. Let’s get a conversation started.

Scroll to Top